Some of the shops we link to are partners who may pay us when you buy through them. This doesn't change which products we recommend. How this works.
It depends on which kind of Brother printer you have. For most laser owners, no. A genuine TN830XL toner cartridge ($98.29 for 3,000 pages) works out to 3.3¢ a page, the same as the $9.99 Moderate plan used to the last page, and cheaper than any smaller plan. Refresh only pulls ahead around 700 pages a month, or on the free 20-page plan if you barely print. For inkjet owners who print in color, it's often yes, because Refresh charges by the page and a page of color costs the same as a page of text. Either way, cancelling switches off the subscription cartridges and your printer has to stay online.
We haven’t used Refresh ourselves. This page is based on Brother’s Refresh plans page, its Refresh terms, and cartridge prices on Amazon, all checked on November 15, 2026.
Brother Refresh Plans and Prices (November 2026)
Refresh is Brother’s ink and toner subscription. You pay a flat monthly fee for a set number of pages, and the printer orders new cartridges itself when it runs low. Brother has a separate price list for each printer type:
| Plan | Black & white laser | Color laser | Inkjet |
|---|---|---|---|
| Basic | $0/mo, 20 pages | Not offered | Not offered |
| Occasional | $3.99/mo, 100 pages | $14.99/mo, 100 pages | $2.49/mo, 20 pages |
| Moderate | $9.99/mo, 300 pages | $39.99/mo, 400 pages | $5.99/mo, 70 pages |
| Frequent | Not offered | Not offered | $11.99/mo, 200 pages |
| High | $19.99/mo, 700 pages | $69.99/mo, 1,000 pages | $18.99/mo, 400 pages |
| Power | $29.99/mo, 1,500 pages | $99.99/mo, 1,500 pages | $29.99/mo, 800 pages |
From Brother’s Refresh plans page, checked November 15, 2026.
Every plan rolls unused pages over, up to one month’s allowance. Going over costs extra in small sets, from $1 for every 5 pages on the laser Basic plan (20¢ a page) to $1 for every 50 on laser Power. New subscribers get a two-month free trial, but the terms say page overage charges still apply during the trial. Brother also says Refresh can add up to two years to your printer’s warranty, and that the laser High and Power plans include drum replacement.
Laser Printers: Refresh vs. Buying Toner
Brother’s compact mono lasers, such as the HL-L2460DW ($179.99 on Amazon), take TN830 toner. On November 15, 2026, Amazon sold the genuine cartridges at these prices:
| Option | Price | Pages | Cost per page |
|---|---|---|---|
| TN830 (standard) | $60.99 | 1,200 | 5.1¢ |
| TN830XL (high yield) | $98.29 | 3,000 | 3.3¢ |
| Refresh Occasional | $3.99/mo | 100/mo | 4.0¢ |
| Refresh Moderate | $9.99/mo | 300/mo | 3.3¢ |
| Refresh High | $19.99/mo | 700/mo | 2.9¢ |
| Refresh Power | $29.99/mo | 1,500/mo | 2.0¢ |
The Refresh figures assume you print every page in your plan. If you print less, your real cost per page goes up, and the rollover only covers one extra month.
Here’s what a year costs at different amounts of printing, using the cheapest plan that covers each amount:
| You print | Refresh, per year | TN830XL, per year | Cheaper |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20 pages a month | $0 (Basic) | About $8 | Refresh, if you never go over |
| 50 pages a month | $47.88 (Occasional) | About $20 | Buying toner |
| 100 pages a month | $47.88 (Occasional) | About $39 | Buying toner |
| 300 pages a month | $119.88 (Moderate) | About $118 | About the same |
| 700 pages a month | $239.88 (High) | About $275 | Refresh |
| 1,500 pages a month | $359.88 (Power) | About $590 | Refresh |
The toner column spreads the $98.29 cartridge over the pages you print. At 50 pages a month, the Basic plan isn’t a good fit either: 30 pages over the limit, in sets of 5 at $1 each, comes to $6 a month.
The free Basic plan looks like the best deal on the page, and for very light printing it is. The catch is the overage rate. One busy month, say 60 pages for a tax return, costs $8 on top, and at 20¢ a page it’s the most expensive printing on the whole price list.
Inkjet Printers: Where Refresh Makes More Sense
Brother’s small inkjets, such as the MFC-J1010DW, take LC401 cartridges. On November 15, 2026, Amazon had the genuine LC401XL black at $38.29 for 500 pages and the LC401XL color three-pack at $54.95, also rated at 500 pages per cartridge. That’s about 7.7¢ for a page of black text, and roughly 19¢ for a page that uses all four colors at the standard test coverage.
Refresh counts pages, not ink. Brother’s terms define a printed page as “any page upon which any amount of ink /toner is placed,” so a color flyer and a one-line note each count as one page. The inkjet plans cost 12.5¢ a page on Occasional, 8.6¢ on Moderate and 6¢ on Frequent, if you use them fully.
- Mostly black text, around 70 pages a month: Moderate is $5.99. Buying black XL cartridges costs about $5.40 for the same pages. Close to a tie.
- Regular color printing: Refresh wins on any plan from Moderate up, because color pages through retail cartridges cost two to three times more.
- Photos or heavy color pages: Refresh wins by more. Cartridge page counts assume light coverage, so a full-color page uses up retail cartridges faster than the box suggests, while Refresh still counts it as one page.
The Catches in the Terms
These come from Brother’s own pages and Refresh terms, not from customer reviews.
- Cancelling switches off the cartridges. Brother says subscription cartridges “will be deactivated” when you cancel and must be replaced with regular cartridges at your expense. Any toner left in a Refresh cartridge is gone the day you cancel.
- Your printer has to stay online. The terms say that if the printer isn’t connected to the internet, it “will be disabled,” and you keep paying until you cancel.
- Not printing doesn’t cancel anything. Removing the cartridges, unplugging the printer, or going offline doesn’t stop billing. You have to cancel in your Refresh dashboard or by calling Brother at (855) 996-0277.
- No refunds for unused pages. Cancellation takes effect immediately, and unused or rolled-over pages are forfeited.
- Double-sided printing counts as two pages. So does an 11x17 sheet.
- The warranty extension ends when you cancel. The extra coverage only lasts while you subscribe.
None of this is hidden, but it does make Refresh harder to leave than a box of toner. If you sign up for the free trial and decide against it, cancel before the two months are up and keep a regular cartridge on hand.
Who Should Use Brother Refresh
- Inkjet owners who print color every month. It’s the case where the per-page pricing works most clearly in your favor.
- Small offices printing 700+ pages a month on a mono laser. High and Power beat retail toner, and include drum replacement.
- Very light printers who’ll stay under 20 pages. The laser Basic plan costs nothing, as long as you don’t mind the always-online requirement.
Who Shouldn’t
- Most home laser users printing 50 to 300 pages a month. A TN830XL costs the same or less per page, with no subscription to manage.
- Anyone with unreliable Wi-Fi. A disconnected Refresh printer stops printing.
- People who print in bursts. A quiet month rolls over only so far, and a busy month triggers overage charges.
- People happy with third-party toner. Third-party TN830-compatible cartridges were selling on Amazon for a fraction of the genuine price when we checked. They aren’t Brother products and we haven’t tested any, but if you already use them, Refresh’s per-page price won’t look cheap.
How It Compares With HP Instant Ink
Refresh works much like HP Instant Ink: a monthly page allowance, cartridges that stop working when you cancel, and a printer that has to stay connected. Our HP Instant Ink math found the same pattern, where the subscription only pays off if you print a steady amount. If you’d rather avoid printer subscriptions entirely, the Brother lasers in our printers that don’t require a subscription roundup work fine with retail toner. They come with a Refresh trial, which you can decline.
FAQ
Is Brother Refresh required to use a Brother printer? No. Brother printers sold with a Refresh trial also take regular Brother cartridges. Refresh is optional, and you can decline the trial during setup.
What happens if I cancel Brother Refresh? Cancellation takes effect immediately. The subscription cartridges in your printer are deactivated, unused pages are forfeited, and any extended warranty from Refresh ends. You’ll need a regular cartridge to keep printing.
Is the Brother Refresh Basic plan really free? Yes, the black and white laser Basic plan was $0 a month for 20 pages when we checked. Extra pages cost $1 for every 5, and the printer must stay connected to the internet.
Does Brother Refresh charge for unused pages? You pay the monthly fee whether or not you print. Unused pages roll over, up to one month’s allowance, and are lost if you cancel.
Does double-sided printing count as two pages on Refresh? Yes. Brother’s terms count each side of a sheet, and an 11x17 page, as two pages.
Bottom Line
Brother Refresh is a good deal for inkjet owners who print color and for offices that print several hundred pages a month. For a typical home laser printer, a genuine TN830XL costs the same or less per page and doesn’t stop working if you change your mind. If you do try the free trial, set a reminder to decide before the two months are up.